But the 1990s advanced more into their direction with the rise of doom metal's popularity. The black metal indie label 'Peaceville' bought out their old catalog inspiring the group to reform to release Be Forewarned in 1995 under the direction of Liebling, Griffin, Swaney, while Joe Hasselvander (ex-Raven) returned on drums but was also able to play bass and guitar. Be Forewarned (1994), and Anatolia in 1998 were also released to growing interest.
Human Hurricane (1998) saw Liebling dispense with the old band to enlist Vince McAllister (guitar), Greg Mayne (bass) and Geof O'Keefe (drums). 1999's Review Your Choices saw the act downsized to only Liebling and Joe Hasselvander, as was Sub-Basement (2001), an album that gave a nod to the act's older style. First Daze Here (2001) saw Liebling, McAllister, Mayne and O'Keefe all back. The "best of..." compilation Turn To Stone(2002) preceded A Keg Full Of Dynamite in 2003 with Liebling, Sweaney and Hasselvander returning, and Paul Trowbridge and Richard Kueht both taking over the vacant guitar spots.
Pentagram went through another complete line-up shift with Kelly Carmichael (ex-Internal Void; guitar), Adam Heinzmann (ex-Internal Void; bass), Mike Smail (ex-Penance/ex-Cathedral/ex-Dream Death; drums) joining Liebling for Show 'Em How (2004).
By 2011 a new reformation was in the works with a complete new line-up under Bobby Liebling (vocals (lead, backing)), Victor Griffin (guitars/vocals (lead)), Greg Turley (bass) and Tim Tomaselli (drums) for Last Rites (2011); a live album of the same title was released that year as well. Pete Campbell took over drums for Curious Volume (2015).