Fred Coury (ex-London) replaced Cortez after the release of Night Songs, their 1986 debut. The album demonstrated Keifer's songwriting skills unfortunately the remainder was uninventive. Their Aerosmith and AC/DC style was popular, add in a raucous live show and hits were generated with Shake Me and Nobody's Fool as their debut chart markers. Long Cold Winter (1988) established their own sound as a Blues-Rock hybrid, and continued their march up the charts with tracks like Gypsy Road, Don't Know What You Got (Till It's Gone) and Coming Home. Heartbrak Station (1990) was less successful; too much R&B was to blame. Shelter Me, featuring a Rolling Stone's feel did manage hit status, however. Courtny's departure made room for ex-Shadow King drummer Kevin Valentine to temporarily replace him.
Throat problems with Keifer created a long break before the completion of Still Climbing (1994); it ended off being a strong comeback. John Mellincamp drummer Kenny Aaronoff stepped in temporarily during auditions; Kevin Conway would be the replacement, as a sign of the times he was found on the Internet. Unfortunately their Glam posturing and crooning was now out of style, and they folded shortly later.
After Cinderella resumed in 1996, a year later, 'Mercury Records' released the greatest hits compilation Once Upon A... (1997) along with a video compilation containing all the band's promo videos from the first three albums.
'Sony Records' would sign the band in 1999, but the band was dropped by the label before a new album could be released; three years of litigation followed.
Cinderella returned to touring again in 2000 and 2002. Indeed, touring was mostly what the band did from now on until 2017 when issues between the members caused their split.