Hoogendoorn, soon after, quit because of incidents during the Mindloss-tour with drummer Ed Warby (ex-Elegy) took his place just two weeks before recording sessions of False. The album sold relatively well in the Netherlands and Germany for a band of the genre. They then completed a European tour with Deicide and Atrocity, playing in Germany, Sweden, Spain, Czech Republic, Slovakia and England.
Gorefest featured an abrasive sound with intensive riffs and melody, and in 1993 they released a live recording featuring this style at the Dynamo Open Air Festival performance, dubbed and recorded as The Eindhoven Insanity, which many argue was the first live death metal album. Also in 1993, they toured North America as a supporting act for metal band Death. Erase (1994), however, proved to be their most lasting performance to date. Gorefest were never your run-of-the-mill grinding death band, but proved to be more cerebral then much of the lot. Their next works, Soul Survivor (1996), and Chapter 13 (1998) a total departure from their roots even showing traces of pop, even going so far as to abandon their heavy image and graphics. Inexorably, fans turned their backs on them and the sales of the album plummeted, causing them to split up in 1998.
Gorefest reformed in 2004 to play various summer festivals in 2005 and releasing a new album, La Muerte in 2005. They produced the album themselves, with mixing by Tue Madsen from Antfarm Studios. In 2006, De Koeyer appeared at EPICA's concert in Paradiso (Amsterdam) as a guest grunter on the song Consign to Oblivion (A New Age Dawns #3).
The next album, Rise to Ruin was released in August 2007; the American release was licensed to 'Candlelight Records'.
On the 15th of June 2009 the band announced that they were calling it quits again, stating that they felt they had gone as far with the band as they could.